Muirfield Golf Club will not stage another Open Championship after maintaining its ban on women members. The Scottish club said voting in favour of allowing female members had fallen just short of the required two thirds majority required to change its rules.
There are a very small number of single sex golf clubs in the UK and roughly half of them are women’s clubs.
A private club is a place where like-minded people can meet and socialise. Effectively a private club is free to exclude anyone based upon any criteria, regardless of how bigoted those criteria may be.
Should The State have the right to dictate to its citizens how they socialise and with whom they socialise? For example, by passing laws banning private clubs or dictating their membership criteria. i.e. restricting the right of free association. Certainly not in a free country.
There are many, many people (particularly on the left of politics) who would like nothing more than to restrict the social activities of the rich and privileged. In fact, they would like to control how society behaves and thinks in general. They justify the consequent legislation, prosecution and bullying of citizens whose views are different to their own by claiming they are eradicating racism, sexism and inequality. This leads to social engineering and the terrifying concept of “The Thought Police” as portrayed in George Orwell’s 1949 novel Nineteen Eighty- Four and Stalin’s real-life Soviet Communist State.
It was in the communist Soviet Union that the phrase “politically correct” was born. i.e. something could be demonstrably true or scientifically correct but politically incorrect because it didn’t support their particular political philosophy.
To maintain a free society we are in the unfortunate position of having to support Muirfield’s right to have a private club and choose their own membership, even if we disagree with their decisions. In the same way we must support a person’s right to free speech even if they use this right to express bigoted views.
If we go too far in criticising the likes of Muirfield there is the danger of populist but well meaning politicians empowering State intervention through legislation, which would be much worse. And when political correctness goes too far we have the additional danger of a potential counter-movement, which could be even more worrying – i.e. Donald Trump and Marine Le Pen.
So, a free society means giving our citizens the freedom to make bad choices and actively supporting that right.